cg17 20.4 KB
Newer Older
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 158
After/in only/rb eighteen/cd years/nns of/in non-interference/nn ,/, there/ex were/bed already/rb indications/nns of/in melioration/nn ,/, though/cs ``/`` in/in a/at slight/jj degree/nn ''/'' ,/, to/to be/be sure/jj ./.


	There/ex were/bed more/ap indications/nns by/in the/at mid-twentieth/od century/nn ./.
I/ppss leave/vb it/ppo to/in the/at statisticians/nns to/to say/vb what/wdt they/ppss were/bed ,/, but/cc I/ppss noticed/vbd several/ap a/at few/ap years/nns ago/rb ,/, during/in an/at automobile/nn ride/nn from/in Memphis/np to/in Hattiesburg/np ./.
In/in town/nn after/in town/nn my/pp$ companion/nn pointed/vbd out/rp the/at Negro/np school/nn and/cc the/at White/jj-tl school/nn ,/, and/cc in/in every/at instance/nn the/at former/ap made/vbd a/at better/jjr appearance/nn (/( it/pps was/bedz newer/jjr ,/, for/in one/cd thing/nn )/) ./.
It/pps really/rb looked/vbd as/cs if/cs a/at change/nn of/in the/at sort/nn predicted/vbn by/in Booker/np T./np Washington/np had/hvd been/ben going/vbg on/rp ./.
But/cc with/in the/at renewal/nn of/in interference/nn in/in 1954/cd (/( as/cs with/in its/pp$ beginning/nn in/in 1835/cd )/) ,/, the/at improvement/nn was/bedz impaired/vbn ./.


	For/in over/rp a/at hundred/cd years/nns Southerners/nns-tl have/hv felt/vbn that/cs the/at North/nr-tl was/bedz picking/vbg on/in them/ppo ./.
It's/pps+bez infuriating/jj ,/, this/dt feeling/nn that/cs one/pn is/bez being/beg picked/vbn on/in ,/, continually/rb ,/, constantly/rb ./.
By/in what/wdt right/nn of/in superior/jj virtue/nn ,/, Southerners/nns-tl ask/vb ,/, do/do the/at people/nns of/in the/at North/nr-tl do/do this/dt ?/. ?/.
The/at traditional/jj strategy/nn of/in the/at South/nr-tl has/hvz been/ben to/to expose/vb the/at vices/nns of/in the/at North/nr-tl ,/, to/to demonstrate/vb that/cs the/at North/nr-tl possessed/vbd no/at superior/jj virtue/nn ,/, to/to ``/`` show/vb the/at world/nn that/cs ''/'' as/cs James's/np$ Christopher/np Newman/np said/vbd to/in his/pp$ adversaries/nns )/) ``/`` however/wql bad/jj I/ppss may/md be/be ,/, you're/ppss+ber not/* quite/abl the/at people/nns to/to say/vb it/ppo ''/'' ./.


	In/in the/at pre-Civil/jj War/nn-tl years/nns ,/, the/at South/nr-tl argued/vbd that/cs the/at slave/nn was/bedz not/* less/ql humanely/rb treated/vbn than/cs the/at factory/nn worker/nn of/in the/at North/nr-tl ./.
At/in the/at present/jj time/nn ,/, the/at counter-attack/nn takes/vbz the/at line/nn that/cs there's/ex+bez no/at more/ap of/in the/at true/jj spirit/nn of/in ``/`` integration/nn ''/'' in/in the/at North/nr-tl than/cs in/in the/at South/nr-tl ./.
The/at line/nn is/bez a/at pretty/ql good/jj one/cd ./.


	People/nns talk/vb about/in ``/`` the/at law/nn of/in the/at land/nn ''/'' ./.
The/at expression/nn has/hvz become/vbn quite/abl a/at cliche/nn ./.
But/cc people/nns can't/md* be/be made/vbn to/to integrate/vb ,/, socialize/vb (/( the/at two/cd are/ber inseparable/jj by/in Southern/jj-tl standards/nns )/) by/in law/nn ./.


	I/ppss was/bedz having/hvg lunch/nn not/* long/rb ago/rb (/( apologies/nns to/in N./np V./np Peale/np )/) with/in three/cd distinguished/vbn historians/nns (/( one/pn specializing/vbg in/in the/at European/jj-tl Middle/jj-tl Ages/nns-tl ,/, one/cd in/in American/jj history/nn ,/, and/cc one/cd in/in the/at Far/jj-tl East/nr-tl )/) ,/, and/cc I/ppss asked/vbd them/ppo if/cs they/ppss could/md name/vb instances/nns where/wrb the/at general/jj mores/nns had/hvd been/ben radically/rb changed/vbn with/in ``/`` deliberate/jj speed/nn ,/, majestic/jj instancy/nn ''/'' (/( Francis/np Thompson's/np$ words/nns for/in the/at Hound/nn-tl Of/in-tl Heaven's/nn$-tl Pursuit/nn-tl )/) by/in judicial/jj fiat/nn ./.
They/ppss didn't/dod* seem/vb to/to be/be able/jj to/to think/vb of/in any/dti ./.


	A/at Virginia/np judge/nn a/at while/nn back/rb cited/vbd a/at Roman/jj jurist/nn to/in the/at effect/nn that/cs ten/cd years/nns might/md be/be a/at reasonable/jj length/nn of/in time/nn for/in such/abl a/at change/nn ./.
But/cc I/ppss suspect/vb that/cs the/at old/jj Roman/jj was/bedz referring/vbg to/in change/nn made/vbn under/in military/jj occupation/nn --/-- the/at sort/nn of/in change/nn which/wdt Tacitus/np was/bedz talking/vbg about/in when/wrb he/pps said/vbd ,/, ``/`` They/ppss make/vb a/at desert/nn ,/, and/cc call/vb it/ppo peace/nn ''/'' (/( ``/`` Solitudinem/fw-nn faciunt/fw-vb ,/, pacem/fw-nn appellant/fw-vbg ''/'' ./.
)/) ./.


	Moreover/rb ,/, the/at law/nn of/in the/at land/nn is/bez not/* irrevocable/jj ;/. ;/.
it/pps can/md be/be changed/vbn ;/. ;/.
it/pps has/hvz been/ben ,/, many/ap times/nns ./.
Mr./np Justice/np Taney's/np$ Dred/np Scott/np decision/nn in/in 1857/cd was/bedz unpopular/jj in/in the/at North/nr-tl ,/, and/cc soon/rb became/vbd a/at dead/jj letter/nn ./.
Prohibition/nn was/bedz the/at law/nn of/in the/at land/nn ,/, but/cc it/pps was/bedz unpopular/jj (/( how/wql many/ap of/in us/ppo oldsters/nns took/vbd up/rp drinking/vbg in/in prohibition/nn days/nns ,/, drinking/vbg was/bedz so/ql gay/jj ,/, so/ql fashionable/jj ,/, especially/rb in/in the/at sophisticated/jj Northeast/nr-tl !/. !/.
)/) and/cc was/bedz repealed/vbn ./.
The/at cliche/nn loses/vbz its/pp$ talismanic/jj virtue/nn in/in the/at light/nn of/in a/at little/ap history/nn ./.


	The/at Declaration/nn-tl of/in-tl Independence/nn-tl says/vbz that/cs ``/`` governments/nns derive/vb their/pp$ just/jj powers/nns from/in the/at consent/nn of/in the/at governed/vbn ''/'' ./.
The/at phrase/nn ``/`` consent/nn of/in the/at governed/vbn ''/'' needs/vbz a/at hard/jj look/nn ./.
How/wrb do/do we/ppss define/vb it/ppo ''/'' ?/. ?/.
Is/bez the/at consent/nn of/in the/at governed/vbn a/at numerical/jj majority/nn ?/. ?/.
Calhoun/np dealt/vbd with/in this/dt question/nn in/in his/pp$ ``/`` Disquisition/nn-tl On/in-tl Government/nn-tl ''/'' ./.


	To/to guard/vb against/in the/at tyranny/nn of/in a/at numerical/jj majority/nn ,/, Calhoun/np developed/vbd his/pp$ theory/nn of/in ``/`` concurrent/jj majority/nn ''/'' ,/, which/wdt ,/, he/pps said/vbd ,/, ``/`` by/in giving/vbg to/in each/dt portion/nn of/in the/at community/nn which/wdt may/md be/be unequally/rb affected/vbn by/in the/at action/nn of/in government/nn ,/, a/at negative/nn on/in the/at others/nns ,/, prevents/vbz all/abn partial/jj or/cc local/jj legislation/nn ''/'' ./.
Who/wps will/md say/vb that/cs our/pp$ country/nn is/bez even/ql now/rb a/at homogeneous/jj community/nn ?/. ?/.
That/cs regional/jj peculiarities/nns do/do not/* still/rb exist/vb ?/. ?/.
That/cs the/at Court/nn-tl order/nn does/doz not/* unequally/rb affect/vb the/at Southern/jj-tl region/nn ?/. ?/.
Who/wps will/md deny/vb that/cs in/in a/at vast/jj portion/nn of/in the/at South/nr-tl the/at Federal/jj-tl action/nn is/bez incompatible/jj with/in the/at Jeffersonian/jj concept/nn of/in ``/`` the/at consent/nn of/in the/at governed/vbn ''/'' ?/. ?/.


	Circumstances/nns alter/vb cases/nns ./.
A/at friend/nn of/in mine/pp$$ in/in New/jj-tl Mexico/np-tl said/vbd the/at Court/nn-tl order/nn had/hvd caused/vbn no/at particular/jj trouble/nn out/in there/rb ,/, that/cs all/abn had/hvd gone/vbn as/ql merry/jj as/cs a/at marriage/nn bell/nn ./.
He/pps seemed/vbd a/at little/ql surprised/vbn that/cs it/pps should/md have/hv caused/vbn any/dti particular/jj trouble/nn anywhere/rb ./.
I/ppss murmured/vbd something/pn about/in a/at possible/jj difference/nn between/in New/jj-tl Mexico's/np$-tl history/nn and/cc Mississippi's/np$ ./.


	One/pn can/md meet/vb with/in aloofness/nn almost/rb anywhere/rb :/: the/at THIDIU/np viewpoint/nn ,/, It/pps-tl Doesn't/doz*-tl Affect/vb Us/ppo-tl !/. !/.
Southern/jj-tl Liberals/nns-tl (/( there/ex are/ber a/at good/jj many/ap )/) --/-- especially/rb if/cs they're/ppss+ber rich/jj --/-- often/rb exhibit/vb blithe/jj insouciance/nn ./.
The/at trouble/nn here/rb is/bez that/cs it's/pps+bez almost/rb too/ql easy/jj to/to take/vb the/at high/jj moral/jj ground/nn when/wrb it/pps doesn't/doz* cost/vb you/ppo anything/pn ./.
You've/ppss+hv already/rb sent/vbn your/pp$ daughter/nn to/in Miss/np X's/np$ select/jj academy/nn for/in girls/nns and/cc your/pp$ son/nn to/in Mr./np Y's/np$ select/jj academy/nn for/in boys/nns ,/, and/cc you/ppss can/md be/be as/ql liberal/jj as/cs you/ppss please/vb with/in strict/jj impunity/nn ./.
If/cs there's/ex+bez no/at suitable/jj academy/nn in/in your/pp$ own/jj neighborhood/nn ,/, there's/ex+bez always/rb New/jj-tl England/np-tl ./.
New/jj-tl England/np-tl academies/nns welcome/vb fugitives/nns from/in the/at provinces/nns ,/, South/nr-tl as/ql well/rb as/cs West/nr-tl ./.
They/ppss may/md even/rb enroll/vb a/at colored/vbn student/nn or/cc two/cd for/in show/nn ,/, though/cs he/pps usually/rb turns/vbz out/rp to/to be/be from/in Thailand/np ,/, or/cc any/dti place/nn other/ap than/cs the/at American/jj-tl South/nr-tl ./.
It/pps would/md be/be interesting/jj to/to know/vb how/wql much/ap ``/`` integration/nn ''/'' there/ex is/bez in/in the/at famous/jj ,/, fashionable/jj colleges/nns and/cc prep/nn schools/nns of/in New/jj-tl England/np-tl ./.
A/at recent/jj newspaper/nn report/nn said/vbd there/ex were/bed five/cd Negroes/nps in/in the/at 1960/cd graduating/vbg class/nn of/in nearly/rb one/cd thousand/cd at/in Yale/np ;/. ;/.
that/dt is/bez ,/, about/rb one-half/nn of/in one/cd per/in cent/nn ,/, which/wdt looks/vbz pretty/ql ``/`` tokenish/jj ''/'' to/in me/ppo ,/, especially/rb in/in an/at institution/nn which/wdt professes/vbz to/to be/be ``/`` national/jj ''/'' ./.


	I/ppss must/md confess/vb that/cs I/ppss prefer/vb the/at Liberal/nn-tl who/wps is/bez personally/rb affected/vbn ,/, who/wps is/bez willing/jj to/to send/vb his/pp$ own/jj children/nns to/in a/at mixed/vbn school/nn as/cs proof/nn of/in his/pp$ faith/nn ./.
I/ppss leave/vb out/in of/in account/nn the/at question/nn of/in the/at best/jjt interests/nns of/in the/at children/nns ,/, the/at question/nn of/in what/wdt their/pp$ best/jjt interests/nns really/rb are/ber ./.
I'm/ppss+bem talking/vbg about/in the/at grand/jj manner/nn of/in the/at Liberal/nn-tl --/-- North/nr-tl and/cc South/nr-tl --/-- who/wps is/bez not/* affected/vbn personally/rb ./.
If/cs these/dts people/nns were/bed denied/vbn a/at voice/nn (/( do/do they/ppss have/hv a/at moral/jj right/nn to/in a/at voice/nn ?/. ?/.
)/) ,/, what/wdt voices/nns would/md be/be left/vbn ?/. ?/.
Who/wps is/bez involved/vbn willy/rb nilly/rb ?/. ?/.
Well/uh ,/, after/cs everybody/pn has/hvz followed/vbn the/at New/jj-tl England/np-tl pattern/nn of/in segregating/vbg one's/pn$ children/nns into/in private/jj schools/nns ,/, only/rb the/at poor/jj folks/nns are/ber left/vbn ./.
And/cc it/pps is/bez precisely/rb in/in this/dt poorer/jjr economic/jj class/nn that/cs one/pn finds/vbz ,/, and/cc has/hvz always/rb found/vbn ,/, the/at most/ql racial/jj friction/nn ./.




A/at dear/jj ,/, respected/vbn friend/nn of/in mine/pp$$ ,/, who/wps like/cs myself/ppl grew/vbd up/rp in/in the/at South/nr-tl and/cc has/hvz spent/vbn many/ap years/nns in/in New/jj-tl England/np-tl ,/, said/vbd to/in me/ppo not/* long/rb ago/rb :/: ``/`` I/ppss can't/md* forgive/vb New/jj-tl England/np-tl for/in rejecting/vbg all/abn complicity/nn ''/'' ./.
Being/beg a/at teacher/nn of/in American/jj literature/nn ,/, I/ppss remembered/vbd Whittier's/np$ ``/`` Massachusetts/np-tl To/in-tl Virginia/np-tl ''/'' ,/, where/wrb he/pps said/vbd :/: ``/`` But/cc that/dt one/cd dark/jj loathsome/jj burden/nn ye/ppss must/md stagger/vb with/in alone/rb ,/, And/cc reap/vb the/at bitter/jj harvest/nn which/wdt ye/ppss yourselves/ppls have/hv sown/vbn ''/'' ./.
There/ex is/bez a/at legend/nn (/( Hawthorne/np records/vbz it/ppo in/in his/pp$ ``/`` English/jj-tl Notebooks/nns-tl ''/'' ./.
And/cc one/cd finds/vbz it/ppo again/rb in/in Thomas/np Nelson/np Page/np )/) to/in the/at effect/nn that/cs the/at Mayflower/np on/in its/pp$ second/od voyage/nn brought/vbd a/at cargo/nn of/in Negro/np slaves/nns ./.
Whether/cs historically/rb a/at fact/nn or/cc not/* ,/, the/at legend/nn has/hvz a/at certain/jj symbolic/jj value/nn ./.


	Complicity/nn is/bez an/at embarrassing/vbg word/nn ./.
It/pps is/bez something/pn which/wdt most/ap of/in us/ppo try/vb to/to get/vb out/rp from/in under/in ./.
Like/cs the/at cowboy/nn in/in Stephen/np Crane's/np$ ``/`` Blue/jj-tl Hotel/nn-tl ''/'' ,/, we/ppss run/vb around/rb crying/vbg ,/, ``/`` Well/uh ,/, I/ppss didn't/dod* do/do anything/pn ,/, did/dod I/ppss ''/'' ?/. ?/.
Robert/np Penn/np Warren/np puts/vbz it/ppo this/dt way/nn in/in ``/`` Brother/nn-tl To/in-tl Dragons/nns-tl ''/'' :/: ``/`` The/at recognition/nn of/in complicity/nn is/bez the/at beginning/nn of/in innocence/nn ''/'' ,/, where/wrb innocence/nn ,/, I/ppss think/vb ,/, means/vbz about/rb the/at same/ap thing/nn as/cs redemption/nn ./.
A/at man/nn must/md be/be able/jj to/to say/vb ,/, ``/`` Father/nn-tl ,/, I/ppss have/hv sinned/vbn ''/'' ,/, or/cc there/ex is/bez no/at hope/nn for/in him/ppo ./.
Lincoln/np understood/vbd this/dt better/rbr than/cs most/ap when/wrb he/pps said/vbd in/in his/pp$ ``/`` Second/od-tl Inaugural/nn-tl ''/'' that/cs God/np ``/`` gives/vbz to/in both/abx North/nr-tl and/cc South/nr-tl this/dt terrible/jj war/nn ,/, as/cs the/at woe/nn due/jj to/in those/dts by/in whom/wpo the/at offense/nn came/vbd ''/'' ./.
He/pps also/rb spoke/vbd of/in ``/`` the/at wealth/nn piled/vbn by/in the/at bondsman's/nn$ two/cd hundred/cd and/cc fifty/cd years/nns in/in unrequited/jj toil/nn ''/'' ./.
Lincoln/np was/bedz historian/nn and/cc economist/nn enough/ap to/to know/vb that/cs a/at substantial/jj portion/nn of/in this/dt wealth/nn had/hvd accumulated/vbn in/in the/at hands/nns of/in the/at descendants/nns of/in New/jj-tl Englanders/nps-tl engaged/vbn in/in the/at slave/nn trade/nn ./.
After/in how/wql many/ap generations/nns is/bez such/jj wealth/nn (/( mounting/vbg all/abn the/at while/nn through/in the/at manipulations/nns of/in high/jj finance/nn )/) purified/vbn of/in taint/nn ?/. ?/.
It/pps is/bez a/at question/nn which/wdt New/jj-tl Englanders/nps-tl long/rb ago/rb put/vbd out/in of/in their/pp$ minds/nns ./.
But/cc didn't/dod* they/ppss get/vb off/rp too/ql easy/rb ?/. ?/.
The/at slaves/nns never/rb shared/vbd in/in their/pp$ profits/nns ,/, while/cs they/ppss did/dod share/vb ,/, in/in a/at very/ql real/jj sense/nn ,/, in/in the/at profits/nns of/in the/at slave-owners/nns :/: they/ppss were/bed fed/vbn ,/, clothed/vbn ,/, doctored/vbn ,/, and/cc so/rb forth/rb ;/. ;/.
they/ppss were/bed the/at beneficiaries/nns of/in responsible/jj ,/, paternalistic/jj care/nn ./.


	Emerson/np --/-- Platonist/np ,/, idealist/nn ,/, doctrinaire/nn --/-- sounded/vbd a/at high/jj Transcendental/jj-tl note/nn in/in his/pp$ ``/`` Boston/np-tl Hymn/nn-tl ''/'' ,/, delivered/vbn in/in 1863/cd in/in the/at Boston/np-tl Music/nn-tl Hall/nn-tl amidst/in thundering/vbg applause/nn :/: ``/`` Pay/vb ransom/nn to/in the/at owner/nn and/cc fill/vb the/at bag/nn to/in the/at brim/nn ./.
Who/wps is/bez the/at owner/nn ?/. ?/.
The/at slave/nn is/bez owner/nn ,/, And/cc ever/rb was/bedz ./.
Pay/vb him/ppo ''/'' !/. !/.
It/pps is/bez the/at abstractionism/nn ,/, the/at unrealism/nn ,/, of/in the/at pure/jj idealist/nn ./.
It/pps ignores/vbz the/at sordid/jj financial/jj aspects/nns (/( quite/ql conveniently/rb ,/, too/rb ,/, for/in his/pp$ audience/nn ,/, who/wps could/md indulge/vb in/in moral/jj indignation/nn without/in visible/jj ,/, or/cc even/ql conscious/jj ,/, discomfort/nn ,/, their/pp$ money/nn from/in the/at transaction/nn having/hvg been/ben put/vbn away/rb long/rb ago/rb in/in a/at good/jj antiseptic/jj brokerage/nn )/) ./.
Like/cs Pilate/np ,/, they/ppss had/hvd washed/vbn their/pp$ hands/nns ./.
But/cc can/md one/pn ,/, really/rb ?/. ?/.
Can/md God/np be/be mocked/vbn ,/, ever/rb ,/, in/in the/at long/jj run/nn ?/. ?/.


	New/jj-tl Englanders/nps-tl were/bed a/at bit/nn sensitive/jj on/in the/at subject/nn of/in their/pp$ complicity/nn in/in Negro/np slavery/nn at/in the/at time/nn of/in the/at drafting/nn of/in the/at Declaration/nn-tl of/in-tl Independence/nn-tl ,/, as/cs Jefferson/np explained/vbd in/in his/pp$ ``/`` Autobiography/nn-tl ''/'' :/: ``/`` 

	The/at clause/nn reprobating/vbg the/at enslaving/nn the/at inhabitants/nns of/in Africa/np was/bedz struck/vbn out/rp in/in complaisance/nn to/in South/jj-tl Carolina/np-tl and/cc Georgia/np ,/, who/wps had/hvd never/rb attempted/vbn to/to restrain/vb the/at importation/nn of/in slaves/nns ,/, and/cc who/wps on/in the/at contrary/jj still/rb wished/vbd to/to continue/vb it/ppo ./.
Our/pp$ Northern/jj-tl brethren/nns also/rb I/ppss believe/vb felt/vbd a/at little/ql tender/jj under/in those/dts censures/nns ;/. ;/.
for/cs though/cs their/pp$ people/nns had/hvd very/ql few/ap slaves/nns themselves/ppls ,/, yet/cc they/ppss had/hvd been/ben pretty/ql considerable/jj carriers/nns of/in them/ppo to/in others/nns ''/'' ./.


	But/cc that/dt was/bedz a/at long/jj time/nn ago/rb ./.
The/at New/jj-tl England/np-tl conscience/nn became/vbd desensitized/vbn ./.
George/np W./np Cable/np (/( naturalized/vbn New/jj-tl Englander/np-tl )/) ,/, writing/vbg in/in 1889/cd from/in ``/`` Paradise/nn-tl Road/nn-tl ,/, Northampton/np ''/'' (/( lovely/jj symbolic/jj name/nn )/) ,/, agitated/vbn continuously/rb the/at ``/`` Southern/jj-tl question/nn ''/'' ./.
It/pps was/bedz nice/jj to/to be/be able/jj to/to isolate/vb it/ppo ./.




New/jj-tl England/np-tl ,/, as/cs everyone/pn knows/vbz ,/, has/hvz long/rb been/ben schoolmaster/nn to/in the/at Nation/nn-tl ./.
There/rb one/pn finds/vbz concentrated/vbn in/in a/at comparatively/ql small/jj area/nn the/at chief/jjs universities/nns ,/, colleges/nns ,/, and/cc preparatory/jj schools/nns of/in the/at United/vbn-tl States/nns-tl ./.
Why/wrb should/md this/dt be/be so/rb ?/. ?/.
It/pps is/bez true/jj that/cs New/jj-tl England/np-tl ,/, more/ap than/cs any/dti other/ap section/nn ,/, was/bedz dedicated/vbn to/in education/nn from/in the/at start/nn ./.
But/cc I/ppss think/vb that/cs something/pn more/ap than/cs this/dt is/bez involved/vbn ./.


	How/wrb did/dod it/ppo happen/vb ,/, for/in example/nn ,/, that/cs the/at state/nn university/nn ,/, that/dt great/jj symbol/nn of/in American/jj democracy/nn ,/, failed/vbd to/to flourish/vb in/in New/jj-tl England/np-tl as/cs it/pps did/dod in/in other/ap parts/nns of/in the/at country/nn ?/. ?/.
Isn't/bez* it/pps a/at bit/nn odd/jj that/cs the/at three/cd states/nns of/in Southern/jj-tl New/jj-tl England/np-tl (/( Massachusetts/np ,/, Connecticut/np ,/, and/cc Rhode/np-tl Island/nn-tl )/) have/hv had/hvn state/nn institutions/nns of/in university/nn status/nn only/rb in/in the/at very/ql recent/jj past/nn ,/, these/dts institutions/nns having/hvg previously/rb been/ben A/nn &/cc M/nn colleges/nns ?/. ?/.
Was/bedz it/pps supposed/vbd ,/, perchance/rb ,/, that/cs A/nn &/cc M/nn (/( vocational/jj training/nn ,/, that/dt is/bez )/) was/bedz quite/ql sufficient/jj for/in the/at immigrant/nn class/nn which/wdt flooded/vbd that/dt part/nn of/in the/at New/jj-tl England/np-tl world/nn in/in the/at post-Civil/jj War/nn-tl period/nn ,/, the/at immigrants/nns having/hvg been/ben brought/vbn in/rp from/in Southern/jj-tl Europe/np-tl ,/, to/to work/vb in/in the/at mills/nns ,/, to/to make/vb up/rp for/in the/at labor/nn shortage/nn caused/vbn by/in migration/nn to/in the/at West/nr-tl ?/. ?/.
Is/bez it/pps not/* ironical/jj that/cs Roger/np Williams's/np$ state/nn ,/, Rhode/np-tl Island/nn-tl ,/, should/md have/hv been/ben the/at very/ql last/ap of/in the/at forty-eight/cd to/to establish/vb a/at state/nn university/nn ?/. ?/.
The/at state/nn universities/nns of/in Maine/np ,/, New/jj-tl Hampshire/np-tl ,/, And/cc-tl Vermont/np are/ber older/jjr and/cc more/ql ``/`` respectable/jj ''/'' ;/. ;/.
they/ppss had/hvd less/ap immigration/nn to/to contend/vb with/in ./.


	A/at Yale/np historian/nn ,/, writing/vbg a/at few/ap years/nns ago/rb in/in The/at Yale/np-tl Review/nn-tl ,/, said/vbd :/: ``/`` We/ppss in/in New/jj-tl England/np-tl have/hv long/ql since/rb segregated/vbn our/pp$ children/nns ''/'' ./.
He/pps was/bedz referring/vbg not/* only/rb to/in the/at general/jj college/nn situation/nn but/cc more/ql especially/rb to/in the/at preparatory/jj schools/nns ./.
And/cc what/wdt a/at galaxy/nn of/in those/dts adorns/vbz that/dt fair/jj land/nn !/. !/.
I/ppss don't/do* propose/vb to/to go/vb into/in their/pp$ history/nn ,/, but/cc I/ppss have/hv one/cd or/cc two/cd surmises/nns ./.
One/cd is/bez that/cs they/ppss were/bed established/vbn ,/, or/cc gained/vbd eminence/nn ,/, under/in pressure/nn provided/vbn by/in these/dts same/ap immigrants/nns ,/, from/in whom/wpo the/at old/jj families/nns wished/vbd to/to segregate/vb their/pp$ children/nns ./.
In/in the/at early/jj days/nns of/in a/at homogeneous/jj population/nn ,/, the/at public/jj school/nn was/bedz quite/ql satisfactory/jj ./.