cd12 20.4 KB
Newer Older
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132


	Much/ql more/ap than/in shelter/nn ,/, housing/vbg symbolizes/vbz social/jj status/nn ,/, a/at sense/nn of/in ``/`` belonging/vbg ''/'' ,/, acceptance/nn within/in a/at given/vbn group/nn or/cc neighborhood/nn ,/, identification/nn with/in particular/jj cultural/jj values/nns and/cc social/jj institutions/nns ,/, feelings/nns of/in pride/nn and/cc worth/nn ,/, aspirations/nns and/cc hopes/nns basic/jj to/in human/jj well-being/nn ./.
For/in almost/rb one-sixth/nn of/in the/at national/jj population/nn discrimination/nn in/in the/at free/jj selection/nn of/in residence/nn casts/vbz a/at considerable/jj shadow/nn upon/in these/dts values/nns assumed/vbn as/cs self-evident/jj by/in most/ap Americans/nps ./.


	Few/ap business/nn groups/nns in/in recent/jj years/nns have/hv come/vbn under/in heavier/jjr pressure/nn to/to face/vb these/dts realities/nns than/cs real/jj estate/nn brokers/nns and/cc home/nn builders/nns ./.
This/dt pressure/nn has/hvz urged/vbn re-evaluation/nn of/in the/at assumptions/nns underlying/vbg their/pp$ professional/jj ethics/nns ;/. ;/.
it/pps has/hvz sought/vbn new/jj sympathy/nn for/in the/at human/jj aspirations/nns of/in racial/jj minority/nn groups/nns in/in this/dt country/nn ./.
It/pps is/bez not/* surprising/jj that/cs ,/, as/cs spokesman/nn for/in real/jj estate/nn interests/nns ,/, the/at National/jj-tl Association/nn-tl of/in-tl Real/jj-tl Estate/nn-tl Boards/nns-tl (/( NAREB/np )/) and/cc its/pp$ local/jj associations/nns have/hv sought/vbn to/to limit/vb and/cc often/rb ignore/vb much/ap of/in this/dt pressure/nn ./.


	How/wrb does/doz the/at local/jj realtor/nn see/vb himself/ppl in/in the/at context/nn of/in housing/vbg restrictions/nns based/vbn on/in race/nn ,/, religion/nn or/cc ethnic/jj attachment/nn ?/. ?/.
What/wdt does/doz he/pps conceive/vb his/pp$ role/nn to/to be/be in/in this/dt area/nn of/in social/jj unrest/nn ?/. ?/.
What/wdt ought/md to/to be/be ,/, what/wdt is/bez his/pp$ potential/jj role/nn as/cs a/at force/nn for/in constructive/jj social/jj change/nn ?/. ?/.
What/wdt social/jj ,/, ethical/jj and/cc theological/jj insights/nns can/md the/at church/nn and/cc university/nn help/vb him/ppo bring/vb to/to bear/vb upon/in his/pp$ situation/nn ?/. ?/.


	Recently/rb ,/, a/at group/nn of/in the/at faculty/nn at/in Wesleyan/np-tl University's/nn$-tl Public/jj-tl Affairs/nns-tl Center/nn-tl sought/vbd some/dti answers/nns to/in these/dts questions/nns ./.
Several/ap New/jj-tl England/np-tl realtors/nns were/bed invited/vbn to/to participate/vb in/in a/at small/jj colloquium/nn of/in property/nn lawyers/nns ,/, political/jj scientists/nns ,/, economists/nns ,/, social/jj psychologists/nns ,/, social/jj ethicists/nns and/cc theologians/nns ./.
Here/rb ,/, in/in an/at atmosphere/nn of/in forthrightness/nn and/cc mutual/jj criticism/nn ,/, each/dt sought/vbd to/to bring/vb his/pp$ particular/jj insights/nns to/to bear/vb upon/in the/at question/nn of/in discrimination/nn in/in housing/vbg and/cc the/at part/nn each/dt man/nn present/rb played/vbd in/in it/ppo ./.


	For/in a/at number/nn of/in years/nns ,/, Wesleyan/np has/hvz been/ben drawing/vbg varied/vbn groups/nns of/in political/jj and/cc business/nn leaders/nns into/in these/dts informal/jj discussions/nns with/in members/nns of/in the/at faculty/nn and/cc student/nn body/nn ,/, attempting/vbg to/to explore/vb and/cc clarify/vb aspects/nns of/in their/pp$ responsibility/nn for/in public/jj policy/nn ./.
This/dt article/nn presents/vbz our/pp$ observations/nns of/in that/dt session/nn ,/, of/in the/at realtors/nns as/cs they/ppss saw/vbd themselves/ppls and/cc as/cs the/at faculty/nn and/cc students/nns saw/vb them/ppo ./.


	Such/jj conversation/nn quickly/rb reveals/vbz an/at ethically/rb significant/jj ambivalence/nn in/in the/at self-images/nns held/vbn by/in most/ap realtors/nns ./.
Within/in the/at membership/nn of/in this/dt group/nn ,/, as/cs has/hvz been/ben found/vbn true/jj of/in men/nns in/in other/ap professional/jj or/cc trade/nn associations/nns ,/, the/at most/ql ready/jj portrayal/nn of/in oneself/ppl to/in ``/`` the/at public/nn ''/'' is/bez that/dt of/in a/at neutral/jj agent/nn simply/rb serving/vbg the/at interests/nns of/in a/at seller/nn or/cc buyer/nn and/cc mediating/vbg between/in them/ppo ./.
Professional/jj responsibility/nn is/bez seen/vbn to/to consist/vb largely/rb in/in serving/vbg the/at wishes/nns of/in the/at client/nn fairly/rb and/cc in/in an/at efficient/jj manner/nn ./.
But/cc as/cs conversation/nn goes/vbz on/rp ,/, particularly/rb among/in the/at realtors/nns themselves/ppls ,/, another/dt image/nn emerges/vbz ,/, that/dt of/in considerable/jj power/nn and/cc influence/nn in/in the/at community/nn ./.
Obviously/rb ,/, much/ql more/ap than/in customer/nn expectation/nn is/bez determining/vbg the/at realtor's/nn$ role/nn ./.
Judgments/nns are/ber continually/rb rendered/vbn regarding/in the/at potential/jj buyers'/nns$ income/nn ,/, educational/jj level/nn and/cc above/in all/abn ,/, racial/jj extraction/nn ;/. ;/.
and/cc whether/cs these/dts would/md qualify/vb them/ppo for/in ``/`` congenial/jj ''/'' ,/, ``/`` happy/jj ''/'' relations/nns to/in other/ap people/nns in/in certain/jj community/nn areas/nns ./.



A/at-hl narrow/jj-hl professionalism/nn-hl 
How/wql explicit/jj such/jj factors/nns have/hv been/ben historically/rb is/bez evident/jj in/in any/dti chronology/nn of/in restrictive/jj covenant/nn cases/nns or/cc in/in a/at review/nn of/in NAREB's/nn Code/nn-tl of/in-tl Ethics/nn-tl Article/nn-tl 34/cd-tl in/in the/at Code/nn-tl ,/, adopted/vbn in/in 1924/cd ,/, states/vbz that/cs ``/`` a/at Realtor/nn-tl should/md never/rb be/be instrumental/jj in/in introducing/vbg into/in a/at neighborhood/nn a/at character/nn of/in property/nn or/cc occupancy/nn ,/, members/nns of/in any/dti race/nn or/cc nationality/nn or/cc any/dti individuals/nns whose/wp$ presence/nn will/md clearly/rb be/be detrimental/jj to/in property/nn values/nns in/in that/dt neighborhood/nn ''/'' ./.
Though/cs the/at reference/nn to/in race/nn was/bedz stricken/vbn by/in the/at association/nn in/in 1950/cd ,/, being/beg an/at agent/nn of/in such/jj ``/`` detrimental/jj ''/'' influences/nns still/rb appears/vbz as/cs the/at cardinal/jj sin/nn realtors/nns see/vb themselves/ppls committed/vbn to/to avoid/vb ./.


	The/at rationale/nn for/in this/dt avoidance/nn was/bedz most/ql frequently/rb expressed/vbn in/in economic/jj terms/nns ;/. ;/.
all/abn feared/vbd the/at supposed/vbn stigma/nn they/ppss believed/vbd would/md inevitably/rb attach/vb to/in any/dti realtor/nn who/wps openly/rb introduced/vbd non-white/jj ,/, particularly/rb Negro/np ,/, peoples/nns into/in all-white/jj ,/, restricted/vbn areas/nns ./.
They/ppss would/md become/vb tagged/vbn as/cs men/nns not/* interested/vbn in/in being/beg purely/rb real/jj estate/nn ``/`` professionals/nns ''/'' but/cc agitators/nns for/in some/dti kind/nn of/in ``/`` cause/nn ''/'' or/cc ``/`` reform/nn ''/'' ,/, and/cc this/dt was/bedz no/ql longer/rbr to/to be/be a/at ``/`` pro/nn ''/'' ./.


	Obviously/rb what/wdt we/ppss are/ber confronted/vbn with/in here/rb is/bez the/at identification/nn of/in ``/`` professional/nn ''/'' with/in narrow/jj skills/nns and/cc specialization/nn ,/, the/at effective/jj servicing/nn of/in a/at client/nn ,/, rather/in than/in responsiveness/nn to/in the/at wider/jjr and/cc deeper/jjr meaning/nn and/cc associations/nns of/in one's/pn$ work/nn ./.
These/dts men/nns --/-- for/in the/at most/ap part/nn educated/vbn in/in our/pp$ ``/`` best/jjt ''/'' New/jj-tl England/np-tl colleges/nns ,/, well/ql established/vbn financially/rb and/cc socially/rb in/in the/at community/nn --/-- under/in kindly/jj but/cc insistent/jj probing/vbg ,/, reveal/vb little/ap or/cc no/at objective/jj or/cc explicit/jj criteria/nns or/cc data/nns for/in their/pp$ generalizations/nns about/in the/at interests/nns and/cc attitudes/nns of/in the/at people/nns they/ppss claim/vb to/to serve/vb ,/, or/cc about/in the/at public/jj responses/nns that/wps actually/rb follow/vb their/pp$ occasional/jj breach/nn of/in a/at ``/`` client-service/nn relationship/nn ''/'' ./.


	This/dt narrow/jj ``/`` professionalism/nn ''/'' does/doz not/* even/rb fit/vb the/at present/jj realities/nns of/in their/pp$ situation/nn ,/, as/cs the/at pressure/nn of/in minorities/nns and/cc the/at power/nn and/cc respectability/nn of/in the/at realtors/nns increase/vb ./.
As/cs our/pp$ discussion/nn continued/vbd ,/, the/at inadequacy/nn of/in the/at ``/`` client/nn relationship/nn ''/'' as/cs an/at interpretation/nn of/in their/pp$ ``/`` way/nn of/in operating/vbg ''/'' became/vbd evident/jj ./.
Realtors/nns live/vb in/in their/pp$ communities/nns as/cs specialists/nns in/in a/at given/vbn area/nn of/in work/nn ,/, as/cs members/nns of/in social/jj and/cc professional/jj organizations/nns ,/, as/cs citizens/nns and/cc civic/jj leaders/nns ,/, as/cs church/nn laymen/nns ,/, as/cs university/nn alumni/nns ,/, as/cs newspaper/nn readers/nns ,/, etc./rb ./.
From/in such/jj communal/jj roles/nns the/at realtor/nn finds/vbz the/at substance/nn that/wps shapes/vbz his/pp$ moral/jj understanding/nn ./.


	It/pps seems/vbz to/in us/ppo that/cs choices/nns exercised/vbn by/in realtors/nns in/in moral/jj situations/nns center/vb in/in at/in least/ap three/cd areas/nns :/: (/( 1/cd )/) the/at various/jj ways/nns in/in which/wdt they/ppss interpret/vb a/at particular/jj social/jj issue/nn ;/. ;/.
(/( 2/cd )/) their/pp$ pattern/nn of/in involvement/nn in/in the/at regular/jj legal/jj and/cc political/jj processes/nns ;/. ;/.
and/cc ,/, most/ql pervasively/rb ,/, (/( 3/cd )/) their/pp$ interpretation/nn of/in who/wps is/bez a/at ``/`` real/jj pro/nn ''/'' ,/, of/in what/wdt it/pps means/vbz to/to be/be a/at professional/jj man/nn in/in a/at technical/jj ,/, fragmented/vbn society/nn ./.


	(/( 1/cd )/) Most/ap of/in the/at realtors/nns minimized/vbd their/pp$ own/jj understanding/nn of/in and/cc role/nn in/in the/at racial/jj issue/nn ,/, pleading/vbg that/cs they/ppss only/rb reflect/vb the/at attitudes/nns and/cc intentions/nns of/in their/pp$ society/nn ./.
There/ex is/bez some/dti reality/nn to/in this/dt ;/. ;/.
the/at Commission/nn-tl on/in-tl Race/nn-tl and/cc-tl Housing/nn-tl concluded/vbd that/cs ``/`` there/ex is/bez no/at reason/nn to/to believe/vb that/cs real/jj estate/nn men/nns are/ber either/cc more/ql or/cc less/ql racially/rb prejudiced/vbn ,/, on/in the/at whole/jj ,/, than/cs any/dti other/ap segment/nn of/in the/at American/jj population/nn ''/'' ./.
But/cc such/abl a/at reaction/nn obscures/vbz the/at powerful/jj efforts/nns made/vbn in/in the/at past/nn by/in both/abx NAREB/nn and/cc its/pp$ local/jj boards/nns for/in the/at maintenance/nn of/in restrictive/jj clauses/nns and/cc practices/nns ./.
Also/rb ,/, it/pps does/doz not/* recognize/vb the/at elements/nns of/in choice/nn and/cc judgment/nn continually/rb employed/vbn ./.


	Like/cs business/nn and/cc university/nn groups/nns generally/rb ,/, these/dts men/nns had/hvd very/ql limited/vbn knowledge/nn of/in recent/jj sociological/jj and/cc psychological/jj studies/nns and/cc findings/nns that/wps might/md illumine/vb the/at decisions/nns they/ppss make/vb ./.
Realtors/nns ,/, both/abx generally/rb and/cc in/in this/dt group/nn ,/, have/hv invariably/rb equated/vbn residential/jj integration/nn with/in a/at decline/nn in/in property/nn values/nns ,/, a/at circumstance/nn viewed/vbn with/in considerable/jj apprehension/nn ./.


	Recent/jj studies/nns by/in the/at Commission/nn-tl on/in-tl Race/nn-tl and/cc-tl Housing/nn-tl and/cc others/nns ,/, however/rb ,/, point/vb to/in a/at vast/jj complex/nn of/in factors/nns that/wps often/rb do/do not/* warrant/vb this/dt conclusion/nn ./.
There/ex are/ber increasing/vbg numbers/nns of/in neighborhoods/nns that/wps are/ber integrated/vbn residentially/rb without/in great/jj loss/nn of/in property/nn values/nns ,/, the/at white/jj population/nn having/hvg taken/vbn the/at initiative/nn in/in preparing/vbg the/at areas/nns for/in an/at appreciation/nn of/in the/at Negroes'/nps$ desire/nn for/in well-kept/jj housing/nn ,/, privacy/nn ,/, etc./rb ./.
Data/nn on/in the/at decline/nn of/in property/nn values/nns in/in an/at area/nn after/cs a/at new/jj racial/jj group/nn enters/vbz it/pps has/hvz to/to be/be assessed/vbn in/in terms/nns of/in the/at trends/nns in/in property/nn values/nns before/cs the/at group/nn comes/vbz in/rp ./.
Often/rb they/ppss are/ber able/jj to/to get/vb in/rp only/rb because/cs the/at area/nn is/bez declining/vbg economically/rb ./.


	Significantly/rb ,/, no/at realtor/nn and/cc few/ap of/in the/at faculty/nn present/rb were/bed familiar/jj with/in any/dti of/in the/at six/cd volumes/nns (/( published/vbn by/in the/at University/nn-tl of/in-tl California/np-tl Press/nn-tl )/) that/wps present/vb the/at commission's/nn$ findings/nns ./.
No/at one/pn anticipates/vbz any/dti radical/jj shift/nn in/in this/dt situation/nn ,/, but/cc questions/nns concerning/in reading/vbg habits/nns ,/, the/at availability/nn of/in such/jj data/nn and/cc the/at places/nns where/wrb it/pps is/bez discussed/vbn must/md surely/rb be/be raised/vbn ./.
The/at role/nn of/in both/abx church/nn and/cc university/nn as/cs sources/nns of/in information/nn and/cc settings/nns within/in which/wdt the/at implications/nns of/in such/jj information/nn may/md be/be explored/vbn needs/vbz consideration/nn ./.


	Relevant/jj ``/`` facts/nns ''/'' ,/, however/rb ,/, extend/vb beyond/in considerations/nns of/in property/nn values/nns and/cc maintenance/nn of/in ``/`` harmonious/jj ''/'' neighborhoods/nns ./.
Discussion/nn of/in minority/nn housing/nn necessarily/rb involves/vbz such/jj basic/jj issues/nns as/cs the/at intensity/nn of/in one's/pn$ democratic/jj conviction/nn and/cc religious/jj belief/nn concerning/in equality/nn of/in opportunity/nn ,/, the/at function/nn and/cc limitations/nns of/in government/nn in/in the/at securing/nn of/in such/jj equality/nn ,/, and/cc the/at spotlight/nn that/dt world/nn opinion/nn plays/vbz upon/in local/jj incidents/nns of/in racial/jj agitation/nn and/cc strife/nn ./.



``/`` Against/in-hl the/at-hl grain/nn-hl of/in-hl creation/nn-hl ''/'' 
(/( 2/cd )/) Realtors/nns realize/vb ,/, of/in course/nn ,/, that/cs they/ppss are/ber involved/vbn in/in an/at increasingly/ql complex/jj legal/jj and/cc political/jj system/nn that/wps is/bez opening/vbg up/rp opportunities/nns for/in leverage/nn on/in their/pp$ relation/nn to/in clients/nns as/ql well/rb as/cs opportunities/nns for/in evasion/nn of/in their/pp$ responsibility/nn for/in racial/jj discrimination/nn in/in housing/vbg ./.
On/in the/at positive/jj side/nn ,/, recent/jj Federal/jj-tl action/nn has/hvz largely/rb undermined/vbn the/at legal/jj sanction/nn so/ql long/rb enjoyed/vbn by/in the/at segregationist/nn position/nn ;/. ;/.
anti-discriminatory/jj statutes/nns in/in housing/vbg have/hv now/rb been/ben adopted/vbn by/in thirteen/cd states/nns and/cc ,/, while/cs specific/jj provisions/nns have/hv varied/vbn ,/, the/at tendency/nn is/bez clearly/rb toward/in expanding/vbg coverage/nn ./.


	Realtors/nns in/in attendance/nn at/in the/at colloquium/nn expressed/vbd interest/nn ,/, for/in example/nn ,/, in/in Connecticut's/np$ new/jj housing/vbg law/nn as/cs setting/vbg standards/nns of/in equity/nn that/cs they/ppss would/md like/vb ``/`` to/to have/hv to/to obey/vb ''/'' ,/, but/cc in/in support/nn of/in which/wdt none/pn had/hvd been/ben willing/jj to/to go/vb on/in public/jj record/nn ./.
As/ql far/rb as/cs they/ppss were/bed aware/jj ,/, the/at Connecticut/np-tl Association/nn-tl of/in-tl Real/jj-tl Estate/nn-tl Boards/nns-tl had/hvd not/* officially/rb opposed/vbn the/at bill's/nn$ passage/nn or/cc lobbied/vbn in/in its/pp$ support/nn ./.
(/( This/dt has/hvz not/* been/ben the/at case/nn everywhere/rb ./.
In/in 1957/cd ,/, the/at Real/jj-tl Estate/nn-tl Boards/nns-tl of/in-tl New/jj-tl York/np-tl City/nn-tl actively/rb opposed/vbd the/at then/rb pending/jj private/jj housing/nn anti-discrimination/jj law/nn ./.
Official/jj reasoning/nn :/: the/at bill/nn was/bedz a/at ``/`` wanton/jj invasion/nn of/in basic/jj property/nn rights/nns ''/'' ./.
)/) 

	There/ex are/ber sins/nns of/in omission/nn as/ql well/rb as/cs commission/nn ;/. ;/.
the/at attitude/nn adopted/vbn by/in realtors/nns and/cc their/pp$ associations/nns ,/, either/cc negative/jj or/cc positive/jj ,/, plays/vbz a/at large/jj part/nn in/in the/at public/jj acceptance/nn of/in such/jj measures/nns and/cc the/at degree/nn to/in which/wdt they/ppss may/md be/be effectively/rb enforced/vbn ./.
Judicial/jj opinion/nn since/in the/at Supreme/jj-tl Court/nn-tl decision/nn on/in Shelley/np v./in Kraemer/np (/( 1948/cd )/) has/hvz rendered/vbn racial/jj restrictive/jj covenants/nns unenforcible/jj ./.
Such/abl a/at decision/nn should/md have/hv placed/vbn a/at powerful/jj weapon/nn in/in the/at hands/nns of/in the/at entire/jj housing/vbg industry/nn ,/, but/cc there/ex is/bez little/ap evidence/nn that/cs realtors/nns ,/, or/cc at/in least/ap their/pp$ associations/nns ,/, have/hv repudiated/vbn the/at principle/nn in/in such/jj clauses/nns ./.


	In/in the/at states/nns that/wps have/hv passed/vbn laws/nns preventing/vbg discrimination/nn in/in the/at sale/nn or/cc rental/nn of/in housing/vbg ,/, support/nn by/in real/jj estate/nn associations/nns for/in compliance/nn and/cc broadened/vbn coverage/nn through/in additional/jj legislation/nn could/md help/vb remove/vb the/at label/nn of/in ``/`` social/jj reformism/nn ''/'' that/cs most/ap realtors/nns individually/rb seem/vb determined/vbn to/to avoid/vb ./.
But/cc as/cs yet/rb ,/, no/at real/jj estate/nn board/nn has/hvz been/ben willing/jj officially/rb to/to support/vb such/jj laws/nns or/cc to/to admit/vb the/at permissibility/nn of/in introducing/vbg minority/nn buyers/nns into/in all-white/jj neighborhoods/nns ./.


	One/cd of/in the/at roles/nns of/in the/at social/jj scientist/nn ,/, ethicist/nn or/cc theologian/nn in/in our/pp$ discussions/nns with/in the/at realtors/nns became/vbd that/dt of/in encouraging/vbg greater/jjr awareness/nn of/in the/at opportunities/nns offered/vbn by/in the/at legal/jj and/cc political/jj processes/nns for/in the/at exercise/nn of/in broad/jj social/jj responsibilities/nns in/in their/pp$ work/nn ./.
But/cc responsiveness/nn to/in these/dts opportunities/nns presumes/vbz that/cs all/abn of/in us/ppo judge/vb the/at good/nn as/cs a/at human/jj good/nn and/cc not/* simply/rb as/cs a/at professional/jj ,/, white/jj ,/, American/jj good/nn ./.
Such/jj judgments/nns are/ber meaningful/jj only/rb in/in so/ql far/rb as/cs persons/nns are/ber members/nns of/in a/at world/nn ,/, let/vb us/ppo say/vb a/at community/nn ,/, that/wps embraces/vbz Scarsdale/np or/cc Yonkers/np ,/, but/cc is/bez also/rb infinitely/ql richer/jjr since/cs it/pps is/bez all-inclusive/jj ./.


	That/dt community/nn of/in all/abn creation/nn is/bez ,/, then/rb ,/, the/at ultimate/jj object/nn of/in our/pp$ loyalty/nn and/cc the/at concrete/jj norm/nn of/in all/abn moral/jj judgment/nn ./.
Racial/jj discrimination/nn is/bez wrong/jj ,/, then/rb ,/, not/* because/cs it/pps goes/vbz against/in the/at grain/nn of/in a/at faculty/nn member/nn trying/vbg to/to converse/vb with/in a/at few/ap realtors/nns but/cc because/cs it/pps goes/vbz against/in the/at grain/nn of/in creation/nn and/cc against/in the/at will/nn of/in the/at Creator/nn-tl ./.
Thus/rb ,/, moral/jj issues/nns concerning/in the/at nature/nn of/in the/at legal/jj and/cc political/jj processes/nns take/vb on/rp theological/jj dimensions/nns ./.



A/at-hl fragmented/vbn-hl Society/nn-tl-hl 
(/( 3/cd )/) Over/in the/at years/nns ,/, individuals/nns engaged/vbn in/in the/at sale/nn of/in real/jj estate/nn have/hv developed/vbn remarkable/jj unity/nn in/in the/at methods/nns and/cc practices/nns employed/vbn ./.
Most/ap realtors/nns and/cc real/jj estate/nn brokers/nns talk/vb of/in themselves/ppls as/cs ``/`` professional/jj people/nns ''/'' with/in the/at cultural/jj and/cc moral/jj values/nns held/vbn by/in the/at traditional/jj professions/nns ./.
But/cc what/wdt significance/nn attaches/vbz to/to ``/`` professional/nn ''/'' ,/, beyond/in the/at narrow/jj sense/nn of/in skillfulness/nn in/in meeting/vbg a/at client's/nn$ stated/vbn needs/nns as/cs already/rb noted/vbn ?/. ?/.
Our/pp$ faculty/nn and/cc students/nns pressed/vbd this/dt issue/nn more/rbr than/cs any/dti other/ap ./.


	As/cs a/at theologian/nn in/in the/at group/nn pointed/vbd out/rp ,/, a/at professional/nn was/bedz ,/, before/in the/at modern/jj period/nn of/in technical/jj specialization/nn ,/, one/pn who/wps ``/`` professed/vbd ''/'' to/to be/be a/at bearer/nn and/cc critic/nn of/in his/pp$ culture/nn in/in the/at use/nn of/in his/pp$ particular/jj skills/nns ./.